Sahabe EvleriHouse of the Companions·Medina

Response to the Jews who greeted with 'Death be upon you' and the revealed verse

The historical event in Medina where a group of Jews greeted the Prophet Muhammad with 'es-Sâmü aleyküm' (death be upon you) instead of a greeting, and Hz. Aisha responded harshly, after which the Prophet advised her to act gently.

Sahabe Evleri

Response to the Jews who greeted with 'Death be upon you' and the revealed verse

Location

Medina, Saudi Arabia

Map

History

This incident is one of the most striking examples reflecting the tensions that the Prophet Muhammad and his companions experienced with the Jews in daily life in Medina. According to the narration, a group of Jews came to the Prophet Muhammad and instead of greeting him, they said 'es-Sâmü aleyküm' (death be upon you). The Prophet Muhammad responded calmly with 'Ve aleyküm' (and upon you). Hz. Aisha, upon hearing this, became extremely angry and replied loudly, 'No! Death and curse be upon you!' The Prophet Muhammad turned to her and said: 'O Aisha, Allah loves gentleness in everything; He does not love harshness.' Hz. Aisha asked, 'Did you not hear what they said?' The Prophet replied: 'I heard; I also said 've aleyküm'. Allah has given them my curse.' This hadith contains several fundamental principles: It teaches that Islam adopts a calm and measured attitude even in the face of provocations; it is a concrete reflection of the Prophet Muhammad's character of gentleness (hilm) and patience; and in this context, it shows the prophetic guidance that understands Hz. Aisha's natural reaction while directing her towards being more measured. [Source: Bukhari, Adab 35; Muslim, Salam 7; TDV Islamic Encyclopedia, 'Salam' article, islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/selam]

Importance and Narrations

Hz. Aisha (r.anha) narrates: 'A group of Jews came to the Prophet Muhammad and said, 'es-Sâmü aleyküm' (death be upon you). I also said, 'Death and curse be upon you!' The Prophet Muhammad said: 'Stop, O Aisha! Allah loves gentleness in everything.' I said: 'Did you not hear what they said?' He said: 'I also said 've aleyküm.'" (Bukhari, Adab 35; Muslim, Salam 7) [Source: Bukhari, al-Jami' al-Sahih, Adab 35; Muslim, al-Jami' al-Sahih, Salam 7]